War and Peace : money where their mouth is

international | anti-war / imperialism | opinion/analysis

Friday January 21, 2005 17:10

by Soundmigration

soundmigration at yahoo dot com

The difference between altruistic human responses and ‘political’ responses to continuing human misery.

The most catastrophic earthquake in recent memory occurred in the Indian Ocean on St. Stephens’s day 2004. The resulting tsunami caused the deaths of 175,000 people across many countries in the region and has left millions more without homes, food, water or livelihoods. Whole communities now have to rebuild lives whilst containing the devastating grief and legacy of all that has been lost.

In Ireland, as in much of the West, the public response has immediate and colossal. Reasons for this include the fact that the regions most affected are popular destinations we’ve at least heard of, and that the disaster happened over the Christmas holidays giving us plenty of time to absorb media images as we ate and drank ourselves silly. But without doubt, the real motivation of ordinary people responding and acting so unequivocally was that of empathy. Even though we couldn’t really comprehend the rising number of dead, or come to terms with the medium and long term impacts, ordinary working class people right across the globe acted out of instinct and solidarity with our fellow man, giving freely of our money and time.

This is in complete contrast with the responses of western governments and their corporate masters. The derisory amounts offered by each and every government have been raised continually by embarrassed ministers, stung by public criticism of their miserliness with our money. Bertie has now raised the 1 million euros to 20 million. Unfortunately previous experience shows that even when little help is offered, even less is received. For example only 5% of aid promised to Iran after recent earthquake there was actually given. Oxfam have already accused this government of diverting half of the 20 million from existing funds!!

The dysfunctional mindset of our political and business leaders enable them to talk up sums offered to repair and rebuild human lives, whist spending and investing our money on the infrastructure of war and exploitation. Tony Blair revised the UK’s pledge from £15 million to £50 million but has spent £6000 million on the illegal occupation of Iraq. Mr Bush has offered £150 million but this is peanuts compared the cost of just one of his stealth bombers, which cost £4000 million apiece.

What about the ‘generosity’ flaunted by big business to the applause of some sections of the mass media. Of course accepting that corporations have no legal imperative to give anything, it is noteworthy to examine just how generous the big boys really are.
The Bank of Ireland offered 1.8 million when it profits last year were 696 million. The AIB has pledged 3 million, a lot of money to you and me no doubt, but it makes 4 million in profit every single day. These are just two examples of which there are many more.

The message is simple. Powerful and rich men may spend lots of time talking about democracy and liberation but they don’t believe in equality. That is why they don’t bother counting dead Iraqis or Palestinians. That is why at least 1million * human beings die every month of preventable diseases and hunger across the globe in countries crippled by debt.

It is clear that our ‘leaders’ and the corporate elite who make their wealth off us do not see all human beings as equally valuable. That is why we have massive war machines, ever ready to bomb and kill for ‘democracy’, but not massive armies to fight hunger, disease, poverty and squalor. This is the reality of the world we live in.

However, the response of ordinary people suggests that we, the great majority of this planets population, do believe in equality and solidarity, and that we are willing to act on our empathetic instincts. Mother Nature may be beyond our control but the ability to create global justice and to share wealth is not. Real change will come when we, the people, make it impossible for our ‘leaders’ to ignore our demands and we remove the structures of enforced inequality and human misery that grind down so many fellow human beings.

*ref http://www.fao.org/documents/show_cdr.asp?url_file=/docrep/003/Y6265e/y6265e03.htm

save preference

Comments (5 of 5)

The Devil went down to Dublin

by The Devil and George Warmonger Bush - Bush Family Links to De Clare

Thu Jan 27, 2005 08:36

666 Strongbow Dr, Ireland

666-Neo-Nazi Ext. 666

With People like Strongbow and Hitler in Bush's Family Affairs are you suprised? The Bush Family has NEVER valued Life and has always viewed victims of Disasters as Societies Dead Flesh.

Think again !

by Richard

Wed Jan 26, 2005 10:40

rik1999rik at yahoo dot com

Australia

Australia is the biggest donators to the Tsunami cause as it happenned in our backyard. The Australian goverment led by John Howard a man who's constantly kissing butt in USA. And of course sent troops to Iraq since a free trade agreement was on the table with the US. They have pledged 1 Billion australian dollars (about 800 million US). By far the biggest contributer. The people also gave alot. The sad thing i red was the since the liberation of East Timor, Australia has been playing the USA game of hide and seek and corruption. Ever since the East Timor liberation Australia has been running the gas and oil fields of this tiny country. I red that irregularities emerged that Australia in fact has taken over 2 billion dollars of East Timor funds and not given to the people to re establish their country under non-Indonesian rule. SHAME ! give on one hands and take on the other . The American way is being used even here on the country of "fair go" How low can goverments go ??

Why not?

by Squarebob

Fri Jan 21, 2005 21:05

You don't have to like Socialist Youth to think that they have every right to hold a meeting about the Tsunami disaster.

The basic point they want to make - judging by the generally excellent articles that were linked to here just after the disaster - is not that capitalism causes natural disasters but that capitalism greatly magnifies the death and destruction that natural disasters cause. An early warning system would have saved tens of thousands of lives and would have cost a tiny fraction of what government's in the region spend on arms. In capitalism the interests of ordinary people always come after the interests of the elite. That's something worth saying and I think SY deserve credit for saying it.

Socialist Youth

by Hnmmmmm

Fri Jan 21, 2005 20:17

Are having a meeting about the tsunami, obviously the message will be global capatalism is bad and debt is bad, join our party and buy our paper.

It's vulture like opportunism

Citigroup’s $7.4m tsunami donation

by fenobi

Fri Jan 21, 2005 18:35

Citigroup expects the total will grow as the Foundation continues to match employee contributions to tsunami relief efforts.

Unplug the corporate war profiteers
http://www.actagainstwar.org/article.php?id=41

Upcoming Events

New Events

Other Press

User Preferences

Feeds

Blog Feeds

Anti-Empire

The Saker

Public Inquiry

War and Peace : money where their mouth is

Comments (5 of 5)