The Wholesome Photo of the Month Thu May 09, 2024 11:01 | Anti-Empire
In 3 War Years Russia Will Have Spent $3... Thu May 09, 2024 02:17 | Anti-Empire
UK Sending Missiles to Be Fired Into Rus... Tue May 07, 2024 14:17 | Marko Marjanović
US Gives Weapons to Taiwan for Free, The... Fri May 03, 2024 03:55 | Anti-Empire
Russia Has 17 Percent More Defense Jobs ... Tue Apr 30, 2024 11:56 | Marko Marjanović Anti-Empire >>
Indymedia Ireland is a volunteer-run non-commercial open publishing website for local and international news, opinion & analysis, press releases and events. Its main objective is to enable the public to participate in reporting and analysis of the news and other important events and aspects of our daily lives and thereby give a voice to people.
Julian Assange is finally free ! Tue Jun 25, 2024 21:11 | indy
Stand With Palestine: Workplace Day of Action on Naksa Day Thu May 30, 2024 21:55 | indy
It is Chemtrails Month and Time to Visit this Topic Thu May 30, 2024 00:01 | indy
Hamburg 14.05. "Rote" Flora Reoccupied By Internationalists Wed May 15, 2024 15:49 | Internationalist left
Eddie Hobbs Breaks the Silence Exposing the Hidden Agenda Behind the WHO Treaty Sat May 11, 2024 22:41 | indy Human Rights in Ireland >>
Debt-Funded GB Energy to Bet on the Costliest Electricity Generation Technologies Sat Jul 27, 2024 15:00 | David Turver So much for Labour's pledge to cut energy bills by £300, says David Turver. Under GB Energy, our bills can only go one way, and that is up.
The post Debt-Funded GB Energy to Bet on the Costliest Electricity Generation Technologies appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
Christians Slam Paris Opening Ceremony for Woke Parody of ?Last Supper? Sat Jul 27, 2024 13:00 | Richard Eldred Awful audio, bizarre performances, embarrassing gaffes and a woke 'Last Supper' parody that has outraged Christians turned the Paris Olympics opening ceremony into a rain-soaked disaster.
The post Christians Slam Paris Opening Ceremony for Woke Parody of ?Last Supper? appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
Victorian Laws Against Priests Meddling in Politics Are Now Needed More Than Ever ? To Prevent Imams... Sat Jul 27, 2024 11:46 | Steven Tucker The Muslim Vote wants Labour to abolish Victorian ?spiritual influence? laws that prevent religious leaders from swaying voters, but Steven Tucker argues that in cities like Leicester these laws are more vital than ever.
The post Victorian Laws Against Priests Meddling in Politics Are Now Needed More Than Ever ? To Prevent Imams Doing the Same appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
Live and Let D.E.I. Sat Jul 27, 2024 09:00 | Dr James Allan Law professor James Allan has had a bet on Donald Trump to win the Presidency for two years. He's even more confident of winning now that Kamala Harris has become the Democratic nominee.
The post Live and Let D.E.I. appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
Three Generations of Waughfare: Alexander Waugh (1963-2024) Sat Jul 27, 2024 07:00 | James Alexander Politics professor James Alexander pays tribute to Alexander Waugh, the grandson of Evelyn Waugh and master of non-fiction prose who died aged 60 last week.
The post Three Generations of Waughfare: Alexander Waugh (1963-2024) appeared first on The Daily Sceptic. Lockdown Skeptics >>
Voltaire, international edition
Netanyahu soon to appear before the US Congress? It will be decisive for the suc... Thu Jul 04, 2024 04:44 | en
Voltaire, International Newsletter N°93 Fri Jun 28, 2024 14:49 | en
Will Israel succeed in attacking Lebanon and pushing the United States to nuke I... Fri Jun 28, 2024 14:40 | en
Will Netanyahu launch tactical nuclear bombs (sic) against Hezbollah, with US su... Thu Jun 27, 2024 12:09 | en
Will Israel provoke a cataclysm?, by Thierry Meyssan Tue Jun 25, 2024 06:59 | en Voltaire Network >>
|
The Chen Case @ the European Court of Justice – Money Talks and a Government Lies
An Irish Times opinion poll (published on Monday May 24) on the citizenship referendum is good news for the Government – it shows a majority of more than two to one (54% versus 24%, 22% undecided) – in favour of the amendment drafted by Minister for Justice Michael McDowell. The poll was conducted as the “Chen Case” hit the headlines.
Were the people who participated in last week’s opinion poll influenced by the mainstream media coverage? That seems likely. The Chen Case @ the European Court of Justice – Money Talks and a Government Lies
An Irish Times opinion poll (published on Monday May 24) on the citizenship referendum is good news for the Government – it shows a majority of more than two to one (54% versus 24%, 22% undecided) – in favour of the amendment drafted by Minister for Justice Michael McDowell. The poll was conducted as the “Chen Case” hit the headlines.
Were the people who participated in last week’s opinion poll influenced by the mainstream media coverage? That seems likely.
For example, Social and Family Affairs Mary Coughlan warned us that this would be seen as a back door into the European Union, and that the proposed referendum was therefore necessary. But closer closer examination suggests the opposite.
MONEY TALKS – YOU CAN’T BE A “FINANCIAL BURDEN”
The key point is that “money talks”. If the European Court of Justice agrees with the Opinion of Advocate-General Tizzano, which is very likely - it will be because the small child Catherine Chen (born in Belfast on September 16 2000) will not be a ”financial burden" on a European Union (EU) state - she has to have a stable legal job, or have access to substantial private funds.
Luckily, for baby Catherine, her parents are wealthy : As Vincent Browne explains : “Mr and Mrs Chen live and work in the People's Republic of China. Mr Chen has a controlling shareholding in a very large company in China, which produces and exports chemicals to various parts of the world, including Britain and other EU countries. He is a regular visitor to Europe.” (Sunday Business Post, May 23).
The judgement has NO IMPLICATIONS for illegal immigrants, or asylum seekers on direct provision or any other form of welfare payment : In other words the vast majority of the relevant 11000 families in the twenty six county part of Ireland.
Yet Carol Coulter told “Irish Times” readers (Wednesday May 19) :
“It is fortunate for the Government that the Advocate General of the European Court of Justice chose to issue his judgment before the referendum on citizenship, as it bolsters the Government's arguments.”
Continuing in the same certain tone she wrote that “In announcing the planned referendum, the Government drew attention to the fact that this case was pending, pointing out that it could mean that those not entitled to live in the EU could establish such a right by giving birth to a child in Ireland.”
This is an example of “being economical with the truth”.
In the Advocate General's opinion, Catherine's right stems from the fact that she "is covered by sickness insurance covering all risks in the host Member State". This child, (not yet four years of age) must have through her parents, "sufficient resources to ensure that she will not become a burden on the finances of the host Member State". Therefore, she meets the requirements laid down by Article 1 of Council Directive 91/364/EEC of 28 June 1990 on a right of residence.
For the families of asylum-seekers in Ireland, the result of the case is a disappointment. Keeping asylum-seekers here forcibly on “benefits” such as the scrooge-like “Direct Provision” scheme, for three years, makes sure they remain a “financial burden” on the state : and are not allowed to work legally.
You cannot invoke EU law within one country : you have to cross a national border. In this case because Catherine Chen is Irish, and she was in the UK, that was enough.
Let’s go back to Carol Coulter’s “bolstering” story in last Wednesday’s “Irish Times”, and read beyond the pro-government spin in the opening paragraphs.
Follow the story to the eighth paragraph and you read this :
"leading Constitutional lawyer Gerard Hogan (says) European law cannot be invoked in matters that are wholly internal to the state".
In plain language, this means that the current Supreme Court judgment – that it's OK to deport the parents even if the kids are Irish Citizens - is unaffected.
This Supreme Court Judgement is a disgrace. It would have been better for all of us if the Chen Case enforced a reversal of this Irish ruling.
Advocate-General Tizzano’s Opinion could produce another "Irish Solution to an Irish Problem" : it encourages people in a Chen type dilemma to emigrate to a different European Union member state where they can get a job.
A BABY POWER TOO MANY?
Vincent Browne and Cathryn Costello (a legal expert working in Oxford University) clarified all this on the RTÉ Radio1 “Tonight with Vincent Browne” programme (Tuesday May 18). Listeners could feel and hear the anger and emotion levels rise in two of the panellists, Michael D Higgins TD (Labour Party ) and Colm Ó hEochaidh (Barrister and Fine Gael member). Further discussion included the suggestion that the Irish government had lobbied the European Court to say the Chen case affected the Supreme Court judgement - and it failed.
The FF Kildare Deputy Seán Power was also a panellist. He was in a tight corner – a baby power among wiser adults. Listeners knew that the flood of Government propaganda issued earlier in the day, claiming the Government proposal on citizenship had been “bolstered”, was looking scruffy.
Mary Coughlan’s claims about “back doors” into the EU were being torn to pieces.
Power began to quote paragraph 124 of Advocate-General Tizzano’s text – or did he?
Ever the vigilant presenter, Vincent Browne advised the Kildare man to start the quote again. Power was given a second bite of the cherry. But Vincent instructed the Fianna Fáil TD to include a phrase he left out the first time. The phrase Power left out in his first quotation was “if problem there be” :
Here’s the full quotation :
‘..the problem, if problem there be, lies in the criterion used by the Irish legislation for granting nationality, the ius soli, which lends itself to the emergence of situations like the one at issue in this case. In order to avoid such situations, the criterion could have been moderated by the addition of a condition of settled residence of the parent within the territory of the island of Ireland.’
The meaning of this is : Advocate-General Tizzano carefully avoids claiming that there is a problem. The unfortunate Seán Power got a verbal roasting from the programme presenter and the other two panellists, especially Michael D Higgins.
Is the Government case “Bolstered” by the Chen Opinion?
No – it has been “Banjaxed”.
Vote No on June 11.
John Meehan 24 May 2004
(This article is based on research by Aisling Reidy and Ivana Bacik)
|
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (3 of 3)
Jump To Comment: 3 2 1Its such an irony that for a group of people who emigrated to hundreds of countries around the world as a result of economic downtime during the 80's and were accepted by those countries they versly emigrated to, do not choose to accept the same status quo when applied to them.The Irish claim to be hospital but do not in any way like immigrants. To this extent they even go as far as deporting children born irish,there by making a clear distinction of a racist divide and second class citizenry divide.
A word is enough for the wise.
Explain what you mean by bully fascist tactics. Explain your definition of what a fascist is and how in any way does it relate to John Meehan's posting. Oh no wait i bet you can't. Gobshite.
Just get over it the Majority of people are for the referendum by a large margin. Bully Fascist Propoganda tactics wont work.