Students’ Unions and Political Parties mix as well as oil and water

national | politics / elections | opinion/analysis

Tuesday February 06, 2007 14:29

by Simon Bolger

Yesterday I was horrified to see that politic campaigns are getting started and soon we will have to endure giant billboards of Michael McDowell face scaring us at every turn. Something you would not want to run into in a dark alley. But this got me thinking about a serious question, should political parties have anything to do with Students’ Unions?

As in how can someone represent a political party as well as the students they represent? It is in my opinion that they can’t, when representing you the students your officers should have no other loyalties but to you. We shouldn’t force our opinions about issues that aren’t yours, as every decision we make goes in front of Union Council to see what you the students think. If this changed we would not be a union any more because foremost and before anything we’re your representatives and should represent you fully and your opinion is the one that matters to us. Not one of some person sitting in an office in Dublin. An example of this would be the split in USI (union of students of Ireland) who we are no longer members of. When their Executive decided to have opinions that did not agree with the 250,000 students that they claim to represent it caused a split that is still affecting them today. This shows exactly what happens to a union when outside factors come into it.

A union should be prepared to go to any lengths for the students but could they go against there own party? In most Dublin colleges not all the situation is different, it would be a hard task to find a member of an exec not affiliated with one party or another. Most candidates get there campaign funding from there respective parties but what are they asked in return? This I can not answer. True if asked they’ll all say that they put students first. But how can a person fighting against fees for third level colleges also be member of the party that raises them. I don’t think you can. I think it comes down to a decision about who and what you think is more important and I hope for students sakes all over this country that future and current union execs make the right decision.

save preference

Comments (1 of 1)

On the other hand.

by d'other

Tue Feb 06, 2007 23:32

At least when you have an open FF head in a union you can argue politics with them. In my experience of student union politics its the wishy, washy "in it for the students" brigade that are generally worse - they have an ideology but deny it. Stuck to the middle of the road like dead rabbits, they are overly determined to ensure that nothing, NOTHING good, bad or indifferent happens in a union. That stalemate of political play denies the very real link between politics and student issues.

The argument you are using now is all fine and good as you are attacking right wing party members. But I have seen the exact same argument used by self described "apolitical" right wingers to attack the left. "Why are you always bringing politics into the union? Why are you pushing an agenda?" is cried out whenever you raise anything progressive outside a letter writing camapign regards student issues. Just go have a look at the current shower in UCD, Aonghus was preferable - at least you could rally against him as a hate figure. That lot just sow indifference. As for the gaint Ents Office that is DITSU...

Upcoming Events

New Events

Other Press

User Preferences

Feeds

Blog Feeds

Anti-Empire

The Saker

Lockdown Skeptics

Voltaire Network

Students’ Unions and Political Parties mix as well as oil and water

Comments (1 of 1)