Cops welcomed with smoke bombs and flares Dublin Pride 19:57 Jul 14 0 comments Gemma O'Doherty: The speech you never heard. I wonder why? 05:28 Jan 15 0 comments A Decade of Evidence Demonstrates The Dramatic Failure Of Globalisation 15:39 Aug 23 1 comments Thatcher's " blind eye" to paedophilia 15:27 Mar 12 0 comments Total Revolution. A new philosophy for the 21st century. 15:55 Nov 17 0 comments more >>Blog Feeds
The SakerA bird's eye view of the vineyard
Alternative Copy of thesaker.is site is available Thu May 25, 2023 14:38 | Ice-Saker-V6bKu3nz
The Saker blog is now frozen Tue Feb 28, 2023 23:55 | The Saker
What do you make of the Russia and China Partnership? Tue Feb 28, 2023 16:26 | The Saker
Moveable Feast Cafe 2023/02/27 ? Open Thread Mon Feb 27, 2023 19:00 | cafe-uploader
The stage is set for Hybrid World War III Mon Feb 27, 2023 15:50 | The Saker
Public InquiryInterested in maladministration. Estd. 2005RTEs Sarah McInerney ? Fianna Fail supporter? Anthony Joe Duffy is dishonest and untrustworthy Anthony Robert Watt complaint: Time for decision by SIPO Anthony RTE in breach of its own editorial principles Anthony Waiting for SIPO Anthony
Human Rights in IrelandIndymedia Ireland is a volunteer-run non-commercial open publishing website for local and international news, opinion & analysis, press releases and events. Its main objective is to enable the public to participate in reporting and analysis of the news and other important events and aspects of our daily lives and thereby give a voice to people.Julian Assange is finally free ! Tue Jun 25, 2024 21:11 | indy Stand With Palestine: Workplace Day of Action on Naksa Day Thu May 30, 2024 21:55 | indy It is Chemtrails Month and Time to Visit this Topic Thu May 30, 2024 00:01 | indy Hamburg 14.05. "Rote" Flora Reoccupied By Internationalists Wed May 15, 2024 15:49 | Internationalist left Eddie Hobbs Breaks the Silence Exposing the Hidden Agenda Behind the WHO Treaty Sat May 11, 2024 22:41 | indy
Lockdown Skeptics
Government Has Just Declared War on Free Speech Fri Jul 26, 2024 13:03 | Toby Young
I Wrote an Article for Forbes Defending J.D. Vance From Accusations of ?Climate Denialism?. Forty Ei... Fri Jul 26, 2024 11:00 | Tilak Doshi
Come and See Nick Dixon and me Recording the Weekly Sceptic at the Hippodrome on Monday Fri Jul 26, 2024 09:00 | Toby Young
The China Syndrome: A More Sensible Approach to Nuclear Power Than Britain Fri Jul 26, 2024 07:00 | Ben Pile
News Round-Up Fri Jul 26, 2024 00:55 | Richard Eldred |
What's to be done?
national |
miscellaneous |
opinion/analysis
Friday March 11, 2005 19:22 by Paddy Collins - Independent mabuhay at eircom dot net Dublin
A few observations on where the left is, should be and how to get there. I’m interested. Interested in the views of as many people on the revolutionary left who care to comment on the ideas contained herein. I should, of course, say at the outset that this is not a news piece in the strictest sense of that term. However, I am hopeful that the administrators of this site will allow me some licence, and at the very least pass my scribbling of as an “opinion piece”. Thus permitting it to remain posted on their site, so as to solicit as many comments as possible. |
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (6 of 6)
Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4 5 6I think if you start off talking of 'left unity' in electoral terms then you have already decided to exclude the anarchists and other libertarians who don't see the Dail as the way forwards. Beyond this the problem with the left is not that it is disunited but that it has failed and not just failed but created monstrous dictatorships in its failures. Uniting those who still see something positive in these dictatorships with those who see them as the reason communism failed it building on sand.
Incidentally on the level of the anarchist movement I am of the opinion that the existing organisations could unite if that was what their members wanted.
Anyway of some interest might be the statement the WSM prepared for the last serious discussion there was of left unity some years back.
would be a great idea, though I think you'd be better off setting it up yourself and taking contributions from party members and independents, that way you'd leave out the editorial problems and disagreements. Left party's in ireland at the moment don't have resources to set up weekly newspapers and what resources that are there are used to put forward the party position, the sp for example has 12 pages a month. The biggest problem though is distribution.
I think that the first thing you would need to do would be to establish some sort of guidelines to give direction and therefore unity to any leftist coalition. The principles of the Peoples' Global Action forum could be a good place to start off from.
Unfortunatly left wing coalitions do not have a very good history, all you need to do is look at the example of the Spanish civil war. I'm not saying that what happened arose from socialist beliefs per se but its failure shows how different hues of socialism can tear each other apart and not the real enemy.
Joe's comment shows that these divisions are still very real in the realm of left wing politics today. Perhaps the terms 'left wing', 'socialist' and the like are far too broad, the differences between the WSM and the SWP are big enough to put them on completely different ends of a scale. Maybe it is impossible to unite the left because it was never meant to be whole, the divisions are fundamental and very real. Here's hoping though...
I apologise, in framing the idea around elections I realise that I showed a lack of sensitivity towards the anarchist position. I understand and respect the anarchist view, although I am of the opinion that we must engage with the existing structures in order to overcome them.
This does not mean uncritically engaging, or foolishly believing that we can turn the structures of the present system to our own ends. Rather, I am swayed by the idea, which emerged from a grassroots movement in Brazil and reached me via a Noam Chomsky interview, that we have to work towards "expanding the floor of the cage". This is what I think we all can do, and the anarchists in their own way while still participating in a broad left coalition of forces. It entails engaging with the present structures, but always pushing them, to be more accountable, democratic and responsive, until they give and are replaced by a new order.
As to the second commentator, I certaibly take your point that setting up the proposed paper independently would be a lot easier. However, the initial idea I had was that if the broad left could work together on a paper, with all of the arguments and problems, then this would prepare them better to co-operate in larger projects down the road.
As for the third comment. I know that we ignore the lessons of history at our peril, but nonetheless I believe that failures in the past do not necessarily guarantee failures in our time. With regradr to the episode of the Spanish civil war, I belive the failings there owed an awful lot to the malign influence to the Soviet Union.
I think, perhaps rather optimistacly, that our generation, on a global as well as a national scale, are better equiped than any of our predecessors to bring about genuine revolutionary change. I think in some respects we have inherited the failings of those who went before us. For example the tendency of some to be excessively doctrinaire (anarchist, trotskyite, leninist, stalinist etc.).
I, personally, reject any grand narrative as such. Rather, I believe we can gain important insights from each of the revolutionary traditions. I always liked the idea Bruce Lee applied to martial arts, which resulted in him being the most effective martial artist of his time, that you take the best from each system and work with it. We should, in this day and age, have the confidence to do just that.
Anyhow, I ramble too much, Thanks again for the comments and please keep them coming. I am genuinely interested in getting the views of as many peoople, of different persausions, as possible-Paddy
I disagree with your statement the party's/groups/indiviuals put in as much energy into tearing strips out of each other as they do attacking their real enemies. In reality the left is only puting up a pitiful resistance against the powers that reign and are negligible as a policial power or influence on mainstrean opinion/action. Of course disputes are further weaking the left and its a double edged sword one side questionable the other repelling people who are politically concious and want to get involved but find this bitching severely off puting.
I am opposed to parliamentary democracy and in favour of direct democracy for the simply reason that i have faith in humanity. people working collectively and respecting each others skills accomplish more than their bureaucratic masters and their sub servants. I still support the green party/ independents(?) because even if it is a failed system of democracy (deMOCKcrazy) it is better to have some sort of representation as a from of compromising vanguard rather than another F.F. Td. I am a hypocrite for this statement as i do not vote.
Your idea of a left weekly newspaper is on the money or infomation how to......up to ta people
I was thinking that myself a while ago.( http://www.indymedia.ie/newswire.php?story_id=65364 )
A newspaper and a combined party conference say .To be honest i am now more wary of the motivation of even the small parties.They can see like everybody else that this atomised atmosphere is not going to get anywhere yet it dosent bother the leadership of those groups very much as far as i can see.Hence i have become a conspiracy theorist!!lol..good luck anyhow.