Interested in maladministration. Estd. 2005
 RTEs Sarah McInerney ? Fianna Fail?supporter? Anthony
Joe Duffy is dishonest and untrustworthy Anthony
Robert Watt complaint: Time for decision by SIPO Anthony
RTE in breach of its own editorial principles Anthony
Waiting for SIPO Anthony Public Inquiry >>
Promoting Human Rights in IrelandHuman Rights in Ireland >>
Israel and Hamas Agree Ceasefire Deal, Trump Confirms Wed Jan 15, 2025 18:09 | Will Jones
Donald Trump has confirmed that Israel and Hamas have reached a ceasefire agreement to end the war and release the hostages, saying he will continue promoting "peace through strength" throughout the region.
The post Israel and Hamas Agree Ceasefire Deal, Trump Confirms appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
Reeves Jobs Bloodbath Continues as Currys Forced to Outsource to India Wed Jan 15, 2025 15:21 | Will Jones
The jobs bloodbath continues as Currys is forced to?outsource more British staff to India?as a result of Rachel Reeves's "tax on jobs", the Chief Executive of the electricals retailer has said.
The post Reeves Jobs Bloodbath Continues as Currys Forced to Outsource to India appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
Woke Paris Theatre Goes Broke After Opening its Doors to 250 African Migrants for a Free Show Five W... Wed Jan 15, 2025 13:39 | Will Jones
A 'woke' theatre in Paris known for its radical Leftist shows faces bankruptcy after being occupied by more than 250 African migrants who were let in for a free event five weeks ago.
The post Woke Paris Theatre Goes Broke After Opening its Doors to 250 African Migrants for a Free Show Five Weeks Ago and They Refuse to Leave appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
Declined: Chapter 4: ?A Promise Not a Threat? Wed Jan 15, 2025 11:29 | M. Zermansky
Chapter four of Declined is here ? a dystopian satire about the emergence of a social credit system in the U.K., serialised in?the Daily Sceptic. This week: Ella laments to see a tractor plough the last remaining field.
The post Declined: Chapter 4: “A Promise Not a Threat” appeared first on The Daily Sceptic.
The Real Reason Behind the ?Farmer Harmer? Tax? Wed Jan 15, 2025 09:00 | David Craig
What's the real reason behind the 'Farmer Harmer' Tax, asks David Craig. Could it have anything to do with the current rush among the rich and among financial institutions to buy up farmland?
The post The Real Reason Behind the ‘Farmer Harmer’ Tax? appeared first on The Daily Sceptic. Lockdown Skeptics >>
Voltaire, international edition
Trump and Musk, Canada, Panama and Greenland, an old story, by Thierry Meyssan Tue Jan 14, 2025 07:03 | en
Voltaire, International Newsletter N?114-115 Fri Jan 10, 2025 14:04 | en
End of Russian gas transit via Ukraine to the EU Fri Jan 10, 2025 13:45 | en
After Iraq, Libya, Gaza, Lebanon and Syria, the Pentagon attacks Yemen, by Thier... Tue Jan 07, 2025 06:58 | en
Voltaire, International Newsletter N?113 Fri Dec 20, 2024 10:42 | en Voltaire Network >>
|
Is Ireland a democracy
 national |
rights, freedoms and repression |
press release
 Tuesday January 06, 2004 19:00 by Ireland Democracy - NUI
call for submissions
Every now and again most of us get the chance to cast a vote for those who aspire to govern us. Are these occasional performances of supposed popular consultation sufficient though to qualify the Irish Republic for the status of a democracy? Preliminary Call for Conference Papers
Is Ireland a Democracy?
NUI Maynooth, April 2nd and 3rd 2004
Every now and again most of us get the chance to cast a vote for those who aspire to govern us. Are these occasional performances of supposed popular consultation sufficient though to qualify the Irish Republic for the status of a democracy?
We would suggest not. Over the last few years we have seen the further centralisation of political power within Ireland, the ceding of sovereignty to unelected bodies outside the state, the relentless narrowing of civil society and the systematic erosion of the rights and protections afforded to citizens and non-citizens alike. The steady accumulation of these worrying trends poses a stark and crucial question for all of those who aspire to live in a genuinely plural and progressive society: Is Ireland a Democracy?
In this conference we will seek to offer a radical evaluation of public life and civil society in the Irish Republic. The papers presented will provide a critical examination of the nature and limits of democratic process and practice in the state. Among the issues that will be addressed are the following:
Are the institutions of the Irish state transparent and accountable? What rights do citizens have when official power oversteps the mark?
Does the Irish Republic have a fair and independent judiciary? Is there one law for the rich and another for the poor?
Is there a genuinely diverse and dynamic public debate on the key issues that affect us all? Do the media do enough to hold the government to account and to allow dissenting voices to be heard?
Is there sufficient space within Irish political life and civil society for the voices of women?
Does the existing public order legislation represent a danger to civil liberties? Is the right to protest under threat?
How much influence do multinational institutions such as the European Union and the World Trade Organisation exercise over our lives? How can unelected multinational bodies be made more answerable to the citizens of supposedly sovereign states like our own?
Is Ireland in the process of becoming part of the institutions of western military hegemony? How can more than 100 000 people take to the streets of Dublin and still have no material impact upon the conduct of Irish foreign policy? Why is Shannon still being used as a principal conduit for American military operations in the Persian Gulf?
Are corporations operating in Ireland accountable for their actions? Why is it that we have the lowest rate of corporation tax in the EU? How come the state is targeting householders who consume waste rather than the companies that produce it in the first place?
Why are many recent immigrants to this country denied elementary rights of citizenship? How can children born in Ireland be deemed not to be citizens simply because their parents were born elsewhere?
The conference will be held in the National University of Ireland, Maynooth, County Kildare on Friday April 2nd and Saturday April 3rd 2004. It is hoped that it will be attended by academics and non-academics, statutory bodies and non governmental organisations, representatives of political parties and social movements, Irish people and those from elsewhere.
Anyone wishing to present a paper should submit a 250 word abstract to arrive no later than Monday February 16th 2004. Abstracts can be mailed to us at :
Michael.j.murray@may.ie, colin.coulter@may.ie or irelanddemocracy@may.ie
Further information on costs, accommodation and childcare provision will be distributed early in the New Year.
|
printable version
Digg this
del.icio.us
Furl
Reddit
Technorati
Facebook
Gab
Twitter
View Comments Titles Only
save preference
Comments (20 of 20)
Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20You gotta love these ambiguous events. Always the opening what is democracy completely sidelining the actual fact that whatever it may be defined as we are certainly nowhere near it. Though then there is the question is democracy really something that we should be aiming for. Do we really believe that the majority of people are capable of acting in their own interests?
Definitely some sort of Socialist recruitment day being planned here, it's all the useal Communist crap about how we are so unfree and how marvellous a state-controlled dronelike existence would be.
Has anyone ever read Parecon by Michael Albert?
If by Parecon you mean "Moving Forward: Towards A Participatory Economy" the answer is yup. The three basic suggestions are fair pay for actual work (ie unrelated to the "importance" of the job but related to the hours and difficulty of the job); a balanced job complex (ie a mix of cerebral and manual work) and I can't remember the third! Good read, interesting suggestions for a decent future.
Its not a socialist recruitment fair, it's a good way to accumulate properly researched data on the state of "Democracy" in Ireland at present and in the past. Although it will probably feature a lot of preaching to the converted, it is likely to be a useful resource for activists to find out details of what is going on.
In my opinion
Hey clown! Are you a communist or socialist if you choose to question the actions of your government?? Imbeciles like you are whats holding this country back from real equality. Anytime someone tries to talk fairness or equality , brainwashed clowns like you use your brainwashed scaremongering to encourage people to ignore the arguments as fallacious..... Rubberhead!!!
This sounds like an interesting and useful conference. I have one question: Who is organising it? Is it something called "Ireland Democracy"? And if it is, what is "Ireland Democracy". I think the original poster should fill us in on this and it will stop silly postings about communist plots etc.
"Is Ireland a Plutocracy?"
Democracy=Rule by the people,
ie all the people in a country rule it, and everybody has equal power and influence over the government
If anyone thinks that the average citizen in Ireland has the same influence over our government as the CEO of Bank of Ireland or Tony O' Reilly, Dermot Desmond etc, than yes we do live in a democracy, otherwise we don't. (this same principle applies to all countries in the world)
Elections dont make a democracy, the USSR had elections but it wasnt democratic because all candidates had to be in the Communist Party and the party controlled the media,
In the West you have to be in the Business Party to get into government (Business pays for election campaigns) and Business controls the media through ownership and advertising.
When everyone has an equal say as to how we live and develope the world then we will have true democracy
The perfect society where everyone is involved in decisions that affect them. It sounds like a lofty goal. However, one person's interests generally run contrary to the interests of another's and we end up in some form of compromise situation. Compromise is what we have right now. If the ruling class had their way then the masses would not have the few comforst they have. Instead the masses would find themsleves even further inferior to the ruling classes. We are living in a state of compromise. We are the middle children of history. Democracy has reached its saturation in the form of Representative Democracy with all its many flaws. Perfect democracy is something that can never work in large communities with the whole process proving wholly impossible to negotiate.
Have we already voted to allow the accession of the 10 new members to the EU. I was not aware that we had, but everyone seems to talk about the countries joining in May. Have I missed something or do we not have to have a bit of a vote on it? Is democracy gone that bad here?
Damn straight lad/lass!!! In the west you have to be the business party to be in government. Its a pity the majority of the electorate cant see this!!
Ever hear about the Nice Treaty ?
In fact the Irish people - one of the few if not the only one in the EU - had a direct vote on this - TWICE - (because they didn't get it right first time) .....
Of course the pedants out there will point out that Nice was not strictly speaking about enlargement - which is in fact correct - although it was sold to the Irish Volk as being "necessary for the enlagrement process" ....
In general there is no popular vote on EU issues in most member states - these things are decided by the parliament. Ireland is an exception to this rule thanks to the late Raymond Crotty and the Supreme court ruling on the Single European Act (SEA) a precursor to Nice .......
However, as you can see it's something which our politicos detest especially because you cannot depend on the people to give the right answer ......
Umar, I don't quite get the point you're trying to make. Elaborate please.
Democracy doesn't get any better than this. It has evolved to the stage from where it will no longer progress. Simply put, ideas of a socialist utopia, where democracy is the rule of everyone and not the few as is the case in a representative democracy, are mere dreams that can never take shape outside the heads of those who believe in fairy tales. In the real world,democracy has reached it's conclusions. Either you like it or you think of something better. All I am saying is that democracy needs to cease being preached of as if it were some divine religion sent down to mankind with which humanity would somehow progress. There are ways in which we can treat each other and provide a better life for all. Democracy is a good concept which has manifested itself, for practical reasons, in representative democracy. However, I believe a perfect democracy where everyone has a right to a say in all decisions concerning them to be neither workable, plausible nor desireable.
I don't agree. I think the top down governance (left or right) that calls itself democracy has proved a catastrophic failure. In the bigger picture the current global state of the world is a disaster. Ireland is lucky to be on the winning side of this global rip off.
On a domestic level the social contract is not being fufilled. We're all getting shafted. By hearing ideas like Parecon you can see that people are trying to come up with workable alternatives to the current state of disfunctional democracy where we are ruled by the uber-rich and the voting public are just another lobby, and not a very important one at that.
I believe we also have an unrepresentative media that refuses to think outside the box (excuse the phrase). As a result we are in a catatonic mist, convinced of our powerlessness. A cosy catatonia.
You say that a grassroots democracy is not desireable. This seems to me a kind of a pretzel logic. If people cannot govern themselves who is to govern them? Other people I presume. Who are these other people and what makes them better than the people they are making decisions for? If you're worried about the unruley mob than you have to consider what makes them an unruley mob. It seems to me masses are whipped into a frenzy when they are misled by the few who own all of the means of mass communication (war for example).
Present day democracy is a capitalist economic fundementalist state of perpetual crisis management, where half of the world is starved to death and enslaved so that the other half can eat chocolate and have playstations. In fact both halves could be eating chocolate and using playstations, if only the ruling uber-rich could find it in their hearts to lessen their beloved profit margins.
We can do a lot better than this don't you think? What's your alternative?
I believe not everyone should have a right to decisions quite simply as such. Should an alcoholic have a say over alcohol policy, or a drug addict over the drug policy, or a criminal over new laws? I believe not. If a friend gave me a gun on loan, and while I had the gun on loan he became insane and suicidal, should I return the gun to him? This man is not capable of making a sensible decision. I confess as to not having found a suitable alternative to the system but do not believe that conceptions of direct democracy is workable. One main problems is that those who speak of these utopias generally never have any plans by which to achieve the ultimate goal. The problem with Russia in 1917 was that they had many of the correct criticisms of capitalism but once power was seized they knew not what to do with it. The Russian Revolution was coup d'etat not a revolution. Anarchists have never been in power so we have no test case. However, with the advocation of no organisation if feel that these individuals will never achieve anything substantial. I am willing to listen to all arguments but as of yet have been convinced of nothing from any left organisation.
You must be pretty pissed off with the status quo Umar - only the criminals have a say in new laws, the biggest criminals of all - those in the dail.
There are those in the Dail and then there are those who rob, kill and cause general choas to a country. I understand that those in the Dail are not the most upstanding citizens by any stretch of the imagination. However, I don't retract the statement that criminals should not be given a say in making laws. Not believing the system to be perfect I don't believe that allowing those who contribute to making it worse a decision will make that world any better unless we decide to legalise everything and let everyone do anything. Then there would be no criminals only your 'ruling class'. Would you prefer that?
Surely the poor Micks in the Dail are for the most part only the wee messenger boys (and girls) for the real "crinnimels" behind the scenes .....
Yes they "make the laws" in the formal sense but in reality they are mostly acting under orders from their sponsors ....
(unless one is really naive enough to believe that all those donations came with no strings attached .....)