Independent Media Centre Ireland     http://www.indymedia.ie

University Heads Refuse Cuts

category national | education | opinion/analysis author Saturday September 19, 2009 16:51author by Fred Johnston

Town and Gown won't meet on this

University presidents in the Republic grieving over challenge to rather large purses . . . So where are the student protests?

"THE CONTINUING refusal of the seven university presidents to take a voluntary pay cut – six months after a request from Minister for Education Batt O’Keeffe – has led to increased tensions between college heads and the Minister. Yesterday, Mr O’Keeffe expressed disappointment at the stance taken by the presidents who earn up to €273,000 per year. “I would have exhorted the university presidents to take the appropriate cut . . . one would have expected that people in such senior positions would do the right thing.”

- So reports today's Irish Times. The report, which makes painful reading for many of us in these times, adds: "In all, the seven presidents receive over €1.6 million in pay. The highest earner is Dr Michael Murphy of UCC with a salary of over €270,000.. . . .UCD president Dr Hugh Brady’s salary was €220,000 last year."

Even giving that reading Batt O'Keeffe going on about salary cuts is a bit weird, people facing a tax upon their children's allowance and cuts in welfare might wonder what sort of world our university presidents are living in. But anyone who acknowledges the break between Town and Gown will understand that most universities live after a Mediaeval fashion walled-in behind a considered privilege. So why aren't we seeing students demonstrating about their masters' extraordinary purses? Universities are increasingly education corporations and their presidents CEOs - there is little or no striving for some higher intellectual and moral attainment. It's about money, trimming courses, knocking tutorial hours away, cutting and cutting again so that the student is in reality a product to be turned out as quickly and economically as possible. So what have students got to say about this? And the rest of us?

Comments (13 of 13)

Jump To Comment: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
author by Davepublication date Sat Sep 19, 2009 18:45author address author phone

I think we need to be very circumspect with regard to anything we read in the [capitalist owned] media these days. There is a huge amount of anger at the extent to which our incomes are being reduced to fund the gambling failures of the banks/developers/Fianna Fail. And just as the media have been up to their necks in the gambling (e.g. inflating the property market with the help of the property 'journalists') so now they are busy trying to redirect people's anger at targets which are ultimately red herrings. People's powder should be kept dry and directed at a more fundamental root and branch clear out of the current corrupt system. This involves concentrating on building positive alternatives!

author by Uneducatedpublication date Sat Sep 19, 2009 20:20author address author phone

well at least they are educated qualified people. Some of the charlies that represent us at government and european level get similar salaries but have no qualifications at all for the job they are doing. Also remember the fiasco where the science advisor to the government and ex GM company employee(!!) got his degree over the internet. when found out he just got shuffled off to somewhere else to continue lobbying for his GM connections.

The current university system has been well infiltrated by business and corporate interests. It's essentially externalising R&D to the taxpayers and also acting as part of the job selection process.The pursuit of knowledge for its own sake is no longer the priority.

author by Educatorpublication date Sun Sep 20, 2009 12:57author address author phone

Another aspect of university pay that needs to be examined is that of full professors who earn €150,000 per year. Many of them do next to no teaching and spend their time on petty university politics, I don't often agree with Batty O'K but I would welcome his promised "forensic" examination of the higher echelons of the universities, all the officers, presidents and senior professors in particular.
The wastage at this level, the ridiculous amount of offices on Quality Assurance that is simply a paper exercise etc. while staff are not allowed to photocopy material for the students. Junior staff as carrying the can for these professors who think it is below them to carry out any ordinary duties at all. They should be forced to take sabbatical leave and have 35% of their salaries taken to have them replaced. The money is not there to retire them all unfortunately. Many of them contribute to little that they might as well be on sabbatical leave ...

author by Fred Johnstonpublication date Tue Sep 22, 2009 13:53author address author phone

Nonetheless, one can't help wondering why students, so concerned about fee-hikes, are not also engaged with this little sinecure business.

author by Illiterate.publication date Tue Sep 22, 2009 14:07author address author phone

"Well at least they are educated qualified people."

I dunno...

I think Samuel Beckett got it right:

"Dublin University contains the cream of Ireland – rich and thick."
.

author by Banquopublication date Wed Sep 23, 2009 13:40author address author phone

The Connacht Sentinel newspaper in Galway reports today, Tuesday, that NUIGalway President, Dr James Browne, "has ignored a call from Education Minister Batt O'Keeffe to take a voluntary pay cut on his significant salary." Clearly not referring to anyone in the Fianna Fáil Party, the Minister had said that "One would have expected that people in such senior positions would do the right thing." But surely the Minister must know that doing 'the right thing' is neither part of our culture nor our Irish psyche? It is completely foreign to us. But it is notable that The Connacht Sentinel takes a less than reverential tone in its remarks about NUIGalway's President. Perhaps the old ways are changing.

The newspaper reports that, while the Union of Students in Ireland has attacked the various university presidents for their cuts refusals, the good old NUI Students' Union has kept a shut mouth: worse, they even back the President's refusal, saying that he was within his rights to refuse the cut.

This bending over to the Establishment in Galway's university can perhaps be put down to the ongoing utter conservatism of the predominantly rural student population who haven't hopped far from home. Reading Che Guevara at the farm's Sunday dinner table before catching the 'bus back to the evil city of Galway simply isn't on. But conservatism runs in the history of NUIGalway's student union and it's hardly likely to change.

Ironically, the Students Who Dare Not Protest have lost the support of the university for their Rag Week, which was slammed this year for its drinking around town and general misbehaviour even by Galway gardaí; so much so that plans are afoot for a strictly on-campus bash next year. Getting pissed and out of hand seems preferable to harbouring a social conscience.

It's hard to understand how any university worth its salt could provide succour to such a cowed and tamed bunch of students. God help us if any of them ever go into politics. Certainly cutting the over-inflated salaries of a privileged few will not be high on their social agenda. Unsurprisingly, this university is based in the city that gave us the notorious 'Galway Races Tent,' of which Fianna Fáil made such good use.

author by Petepublication date Wed Sep 23, 2009 17:57author address author phone

"The Connacht Sentinel newspaper in Galway reports today, Tuesday, that NUI Galway President, Dr James Browne, "has ignored a call from Education Minister Batt O'Keeffe to take a voluntary pay cut on his significant salary."

James Browne is a humble employee of the Irish Taxpayer.

It is up to Batt O'Keefe to TELL Browne what the Irish taxpayer is going to pay him.

(Most people in Galway.....never mind the world... never heard of Dr. James Browne.
Such is his.........MAGNIFICENCE............in World Civilisation.)
.

author by cheebapublication date Wed Sep 23, 2009 21:26author address author phone

From the ST university league table;

STUDENT VIEW

Donna Cummins, students’ union president:

First impressions There’s a wonderful atmosphere, brimming with activity.
Worst feature A lack of parking on campus.
Facilities No shortage of entertainment on offer.
Deal clincher Sport clubs and societies ensure that everyone can get involved.

So what is most enraging the NUIGSU is the lack of parking...

Hmmm, must agree with all posters above.

author by Louis the Lastpublication date Sat Sep 26, 2009 19:36author address author phone

Seems to me the USI have no right to protest against the introduction of fees if they won't say something about this little game.

author by Fred Johnstonpublication date Sun Sep 27, 2009 16:07author address author phone

Dozens of NUIGalway academics have signed a YES petition published in local newspapers. Is this university the most conservative in the country?

author by Sid the Stoodentpublication date Mon Sep 28, 2009 13:30author address author phone

And on top of the comfortable quarter million euro per annum one must not forget:

- The Des Res: an on-site, all-services included, fully furnished and maintained home well beyond the means of most ordinary mortals, including (one has to add) people on a mere quarter million;

- The Company Car: not just a vehicle, but a driver too, and overnight accomodation for both when travelling any further than Dunnes Stores;

- The Home Plan: I doubt anyone has added the amounts each University President has gleefully expended on the massive refurbishment of their own homes, ultimately at taxpayer expense, whilst in office;

- The Family and Friends Tariff: free travel and accommodation for the more desirable outings;

- The Tax Break: well no tax on the above for starters, but also add in all the deductibles when your home is your primary place of work;

- Nice Little Earners: like a few directorships, Opera House patrons' passes, etc.

In the case of Trinners, I would guess you could double the basic package with all these extras. And some of these Very Important Presidents also happen to be eligible for a free bus pass, but I doubt they bother.

author by Hurler in the Ditchpublication date Mon Sep 28, 2009 19:31author address author phone

So why is NUIGalway's SU so silent? This is the university that gets more money than God thrown at it because it is an 'Irish-Language' University yet cuts the hours for its Irish language courses? The university that, far too late, gave the late great poet, Máirtín O Direáin a writers' residency while ignoring him for years? The Lit & Deb can have all the someday lawyers and architects jumping up and down shouting 'Point of Order!' and making out like their in the real world, but not one of them will raise a voice in these times of recession when seven university presidents give the finger to any suggestion that they should cut their enormous salaries.

author by Bardopublication date Sun Oct 11, 2009 15:14author address author phone

So why has this story gone away? central issue - why don't the students' union at NUIGalway make a statement about this?


http://www.indymedia.ie/article/94118

Indymedia Ireland is a media collective. We are independent volunteer citizen journalists producing and distributing the authentic voices of the people. Indymedia Ireland is an open news project where anyone can post their own news, comment, videos or photos about Ireland or related matters.